To consolidate, disseminate, and gather information concerning the 710 expansion into our San Rafael neighborhood and into our surrounding neighborhoods. If you have an item that you would like posted on this blog, please e-mail the item to Peggy Drouet at firstname.lastname@example.org
Tuesday, December 24, 2013
Lung cancer: A cloud on China's polluted horizon
China's doctors are beginning to speak of a link between air
pollution and lung cancer. Children as young as 8 have been treated.
A man flies a kite in Shanghai. This month, the city had an air
pollution reading of 500 for the first time, prompting authorities to
order children and the elderly to remain indoors. Beijing and other
parts of northern China have pollution that is even higher.
BEIJING — The youngest known lung cancer
patient in eastern China is an 8-year-old girl whose home is next to a
dust-choked road in heavily industrialized Jiangsu province.
Another patient was a 14-year-old girl from Shanghai, the daughter of two nonsmokers with no family history of lung cancer.
Back in the 1970s, when Bai Chunxue was in medical school, the
textbook lung cancer patient was a chain-smoking male in his 60s.
Nowadays, Bai, one of the physicians who treated the teen, sees so many
who are still in their 20s that the cases blend together.
"When I see patients who are
not smokers with no other risk factors, we have to assume that the most
probable cause is pollution," said Bai, who works at Shanghai's
Zhongshan Hospital and is chairman of the Shanghai Respiratory Research
Increasingly, other Chinese physicians are reaching the same
conclusion. At a time when cigarette smoking is on the decline in China,
the nation is facing an explosion of lung cancer cases.
From 2002 to 2011, the incidence of lung cancer in Beijing rose to 63
cases per 100,000, from 39.6, according to municipal health
authorities. Nationwide in the last three decades, an era in which China
opened up its economy and industrialized, deaths from lung cancer have
In a country that manufactures 1.7 trillion cigarettes a year,
smoking is still cited as the leading cause of lung cancer. But these
days, only about half of Chinese men smoke, down from 63% in 1996.
The additional culprit, doctors believe, is the fine particulate
matter known as PM 2.5, the microscopic particles from exhaust, coal
smoke and vehicle fumes that can burrow their way into lungs.
Readings in Beijing and elsewhere in northern China frequently climb
straight off the chart devised by the World Health Organization, which
classifies particulate levels between 300 and 500 micrograms per cubic
meter as hazardous.
The northeastern city of Harbin practically closed down for two days
in October when readings approached 1,000, creating air so murky that
residents said they couldn't see their dogs at the end of the leash.
The episode was reminiscent of the famous London smog of December
1952, when deadly pollution caused in large part by the burning of coal
lasted for five days, leading to an estimated 12,000 premature deaths,
according to a 2002 study by British health officials.
As with London, the Harbin "airpocalypse," as it was dubbed, was
caused mostly by coal, which remains the major heating source in China.
In January, Beijing experienced levels of pollution nearly as high; this
month, far-less-polluted Shanghai hit the 500 level for the first time,
prompting authorities to order children and the elderly to remain
Although China's Communist Party is more candid about pollution than
it used to be, the topic remains a sensitive one. Many Chinese doctors
and researchers turn down requests for interviews, saying it's too risky
to speak to foreign journalists.
Wei Zhang, a Chinese-born cancer researcher at the University of
Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center in Houston, said he was stunned that so
few speakers mentioned pollution at a major conference on cancer last
month in Tianjin.
"In the plenary session, I think I was the only person who brought up the term 'air pollution,'" Zhang said.
"Ten years ago, it was sensitive to talk about smoking because the
tobacco industry was so important to the Chinese economy. Now it feels
safe to talk about smoking. But for pollution, people are not prepared
to talk about it," he said.
Though the Chinese news media are replete with stories about
pollution, connecting the dots between dirty air and the rising cancer
rate is risky. The doctor who first disclosed the case of the 8-year-old
girl with lung cancer last month to a reporter from the state-run China
News Service appears to have been publicly silenced.
"There was a misunderstanding. I can't do an interview," said Feng Dongjie of the Jiangsu Province Tumor Hospital in Nanjing.
Researchers at Fudan University School of Public Health in Shanghai
were chastised last month for reporting on an experiment in which water
contaminated with fine particulate matter was injected into the lungs of
Photos of the blackened lungs went viral on Chinese social media
sites before China's state media jumped in, running large editorials
attacking the researchers for injecting the solution rather than letting
the mice breathe polluted air.
"The dramatic imagery whipped Net users into a frenzy," complained
the Global Times, a newspaper close to the Communist Party, which went
on to quote the chief researcher on the experiment, Song Weimin, saying
that "the effects have been exaggerated in media reports and the effects
on humans will not be so severe."
European researchers, however, say the techniques used at Fudan are legitimate.
"Injection is a fairly standard procedure with animal experiments
because it is very hard to do inhalation studies with rodents. They are
not very cooperative in that way," said Dana Loomis, a leading expert on
outdoor air pollution with the World Health Organization's
International Agency for Research on Cancer.
In October, the agency formally classified outdoor air pollution as a major carcinogen.
"With the levels of pollution existing in Europe, the risks
associated with exposure to air pollution are comparable to passive
smoking," Loomis said. "You could expect higher risks in more polluted
Another WHO agency reported in 2010 that air pollution was
responsible for 3.2 million deaths worldwide, 223,000 of them from lung
cancer. About half the cases are believed to have been in Asia.
Yet research on the connection between pollution and lung cancer remains in its infancy in China.
To learn more, researchers say, Chinese health authorities must
establish cancer registries, collecting case histories of new patients.
Those records then must be matched with detailed air pollution data
going back over the years it takes for lung cancer to develop.
"It is not going to be easy laboratory research. You need to buildup
an infrastructure over time," Zhang said. "And of course, the Chinese
government has to come on board so researchers don't feel like they're
doing something secret."